National Service debate

National Service debate

Police chief Alf Hitchcock has revealed a possible plan for dealing with unemployed teenagers. While Brooke Kinsella (former Eastenders actress whose brother was stabbed) has called for young people to be conscripted into mandatory National Service. Between 1945 and 1963, 2.5 million young men did their time in National Service. How would you feel if we had National Service today? Would it deal with the perceived current issues around teenage behaviour?

Plus: discuss this topic in depth in the forum

Looking for a chat?
Our comment boards are for on-topic discussion only. If you want to meet like-minded people and just shoot the breeze, the registered forums are what you're after. Find a forum that suits you and get nattering.

 

Your comments

 
  1.  
    dave from bournemouth says:
    Oct 15, 13:36

    Spot on ! If teenagers cannot or will not get a job and insist on being troublesome at the least it will instill some respect for others, bring back national Service

  2.  
    Steve from Berkshire says:
    Aug 22, 08:31

    Kerry - In today's society, it would clearly be unacceptable to have a National Service system that applied only to boys. As you are not getting any replies, here is a repost of my comments on July 16th.
    "The general assumption seems to be that National Service would only apply to boys! Presumably in our "gender neutral" age, any National Service, whether military or community based, would apply equally to girls. There is no justification today for the sexist National Service which still exists in some EU countries (why isn't it banned?) where boys have to give up a couple of years of their life but girls don't. To make matters worse, in some countries girls are offered the option to do National Service (following complaints that excluding them was sexist!) but it is not obligatory. National Service should be covered by the same anti sexist laws as everything else."
    The general assumption seems to be that National Service would only apply to boys! Presumably in our "gender neutral" age, any National Service, whether military or community based, would apply equally to girls. There is no justification today for the sexist National Service which still exists in some EU countries (why isn't it banned?) where boys have to give up a couple of years of their life but girls don't. To make matters worse, in some countries girls are offered the option to do National Service (following complaints that excluding them was sexist!) but it is not obligatory. National Service should be covered by the same anti sexist laws as everything else.

  3.  
    big colin from scunthorpe says:
    Aug 10, 22:48

    I am in partial aggreement with MAT from LonDon , but you cant put all the blame onto parents MAT, iff i think its time to smack my childs aris in order to instill discaplin into him i will be castigated by (society)
    and probably go to prison. No mate,i am speaking from expearience
    i had to do my national service in 1948 and it did us ALL the world of good ., DO YOU REALISE ? That when you hear people talking about our brave boys who are in IRAQ , and how dangerous it is out there
    that there are more deaths through stabings and shooting on the streets of Britain than there are in IRAQ, its time to stop pussyfooting around get a regimental sargentmajor in thier face and teach them some manners

  4.  
    Kerry from Kent says:
    Jul 30, 09:30

    Bad Lads Army, yes I saw that, how about the "Bad Girls" then?

  5.  
    dave from up north says:
    Jul 29, 21:55

    Simple answer YES .did anyone see bad lads army the programme is spot on

Report this comment:

This will never be published on the site.

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

 

Comments page 1 of 499

Post a comment:

 

This comment board is reactively moderated.

Debate status

  • Total comments : 2,633
  • Allowed comments : 2,492
  • Blocked comments : 141
  • Waiting for moderation : 0