X Factor: should Emily have walked?

X Factor: should Emily have walked?

X Factor's Emily Nakanda has been caught in two videos which show her being violent. Firstly towards a boy with a knife, saying: "I will cut your eyes out. Yeah!" and then happy slapping another girl. She has now walked out of the show but should she have been allowed to continue in the first place after these videos were exposed?

 

Your comments

 
  1.  
    Amanda from Scotland says:
    Dec 15, 17:54

    Yes, it was the mature thing to do for her to leave the show. A lot was made of how she had overcome her own difficulties, but it seems that she was also pretty nasty to others. in my view, she is not yet old enough to have repaired the situation and put it behind her. Maybe in future she can use her voice to make a difference to her own and other people's lives.

  2.  
    melanie from Port Talbot says:
    Dec 15, 15:55

    She shouldn't have walked but I understand why she did because she may have been pushed out but that sent Sharon's chances of winning up in smoke

  3.  
    Emilyy from Portsmouthh says:
    Dec 15, 11:58

    Emily shudnt of walked! all of her past behaviour was from ages ago! and she was probably only doin it to impress others! she herslef was probably a victim aswell! she was the best there n shudda won!! X

  4.  
    .. from .. says:
    Dec 14, 11:20

    It's a good thing she is off the show.

    She is a nasty little bully.

  5.  
    DP from Kent says:
    Dec 14, 11:12

    Yes, this was the riht decision to throw the nasty bully off the show. She couldn't sing anyway, she was hideously out of key all the time. Society should not reward bad behaviour and this is a good example of us not doing that. Nasty little bitch as she is.

Report this comment:

This will never be published on the site.

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

 

Comments page 7 of 162

This comment board is closed.

Debate status

  • Total comments : 865
  • Allowed comments : 808
  • Blocked comments : 57
  • Waiting for moderation : 0