X Factor: should Emily have walked?

X Factor: should Emily have walked?

X Factor's Emily Nakanda has been caught in two videos which show her being violent. Firstly towards a boy with a knife, saying: "I will cut your eyes out. Yeah!" and then happy slapping another girl. She has now walked out of the show but should she have been allowed to continue in the first place after these videos were exposed?

 

Your comments

 
  1.  
    sjkfhureoohnv from ireland says:
    Dec 24, 21:20

    i think she deserved to leave, to be honest.

  2.  
    Ann from Oxford says:
    Dec 18, 14:20

    She should have gone, no one should be doing this sort of thing at all. The only thing is Sharon should have been alowed to bring in one of the girls she turned down when they were doing the final 5 or whatever it was, that would have made it fair

  3.  
    janet weston from Gloucester says:
    Dec 18, 10:50

    I am not sure how long the gap was for doing these acts or doing the x-factor. What Emily Nakanda had done was wrong and I think she knows it we have all done things wrong and I hope that we have learned from them (but not give someone a second chance is wrong) at least she has said that she did do it So I hope she can move on from this and keep with the right kind of people that will up left her and not pull her down.

    The one who has done no wrong,I would like to meet this person.

    we have all done things wrong so do not judge her. help her to move on and to become a better person. Good Luck

    Emily Nakanda

  4.  
    sighsindisbeleif from uk says:
    Dec 17, 17:13

    No. She should have been frog marched off! We are forever giving the message out in this hemisphere, that it's okay to do bad things if you're on telly. It's not! Youth is no excuse either - she was old to know what she was doing was wrong, simple as that. I don't doubt that she regrets it now, but whether she regrets it for the right reasons, or for purely selfish ones, only she could say. It's something she'll have to learn to forgive herself for though, if she's to move on at all...

  5.  
    jj from anywhere says:
    Dec 16, 23:23

    I am afaid the only answer would have to be a yes,But if I could get a message through to her it would be get your self in order and if singing is what your really about then dont no matter what the media or who ever gives you grief about all this,remember we should all be allowed to redeem our selves especialy as your so young and dumb for doing what you did, so still carry on your dream

Report this comment:

This will never be published on the site.

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

 

Comments page 6 of 162

This comment board is closed.

Debate status

  • Total comments : 865
  • Allowed comments : 808
  • Blocked comments : 57
  • Waiting for moderation : 0