Catherine Tate v Freema Agyeman

Catherine Tate landed the role of Doctor Who's new companion, reprising her role as Donna from the 2006 Christmas special in the new BBC series. Meanwhile, Freema Agyeman, who played the Doctor's existing companion Martha Jones, only gets to return mid-series. Has Freema been snubbed in favour of Catherine? Who is the better companion for the Doctor?

Your comments

Add your comment

linda from liverpool says:

Jul 17, 16:03

Billie Piper was second to none bring her back PLEASE. Love 'ms Tate but she was awful at xmas and just wont be right.

Report this comment
spud from leeds says:

Jul 17, 15:52

cath tate is too old! freema agyemen is young, sassy and strong! NO CONTEST!!!!

Report this comment
spud from leeds says:

Jul 17, 15:37

i agree with scott from birmingham! i have watched it for 35 years myself! loved jon pertwee & tom baker. love the cgi graphics on the present DR WHO revival

Report this comment
spud from leeds says:

Jul 17, 15:17

cath tate is too old! freema agyemen is young, sassy and strong! NO CONTEST!!!!

Report this comment
spud from leeds says:

Jul 17, 15:10

billie piper for me!better actress than a singer! bring her back, anything is possible in doctor who!!!

Report this comment

Report this comment:

Which comment would you like to report?

Name:

Your email address:

This will never be published on the site.

URL please leave empty:

Can we reply to you?

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Your reason for reporting this comment:

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

Please provide more details:

Comments page 8 of 22

This comment board is closed.

See our moderation guide

Debate status

Total comments : 118
Allowed comments : 110
Blocked comments : 8
Waiting for moderation : 0