Catherine Tate v Freema Agyeman

Catherine Tate v Freema Agyeman

Catherine Tate landed the role of Doctor Who's new companion, reprising her role as Donna from the 2006 Christmas special in the new BBC series. Meanwhile, Freema Agyeman, who played the Doctor's existing companion Martha Jones, only gets to return mid-series. Has Freema been snubbed in favour of Catherine? Who is the better companion for the Doctor?

 

Your comments

 
  1.  
    amber jane cutcliffe from springfield road says:
    Jul 12, 16:08

    i like them both, but martha really is the best

  2.  
    Tülin from UK says:
    Jul 12, 16:07

    I can't decide. I think I'll give Catherine a chance, and decide for myself then. I am looking forward for the Christmas episode. It's a shame that the series is so short, and we have to wait til next year for the next series ;_;

  3.  
    Issy from Bedfordshire says:
    Jul 12, 14:28

    I agree with George - Catherine Tate just plays Catherine Tate - can't we have a decent actress (like the last two) playing the part?

  4.  
    Catherine Graham from boro says:
    Jul 12, 14:23

    While the final episode of Series Three, screened last Saturday , saw The Doctor's companion Martha leave to care for her devastated family, and to break the cycle of unrequited love she feels for The Doctor, the production team has now confirmed that the character is set to make a triumphant return in the fourth series.

    Freema Agyeman is also set to join the cast of Torchwood, where she will continue to play the character in three new episodes before returning to Doctor Who in the middle of the fourth series.

  5.  
    Catherine Graham from Middlesbrough says:
    Jul 12, 14:01

    I loved Rose as the doctors assistant. Martha was a good follow on but as for Catherine Tate.... really not sure about her.... i think she is alittle too old to be honest..... i cant see a romance between her and the doctor just a friendship. Also i cant get away from her Lauren character!
    I will miss Martha just like i missed Rose

Report this comment:

This will never be published on the site.

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

 

Comments page 11 of 22

This comment board is closed.

Debate status

  • Total comments : 118
  • Allowed comments : 110
  • Blocked comments : 8
  • Waiting for moderation : 0