1.  
   Linda from Suffolk says:

   Jul 17, 12:15

   Definitely Rose, with Martha a very close second. Dr Who had real chemistry with Rose, a blink & you'll miss it thing with Martha. Catherine Tate just won't do. She is simply not right & a lot of Dr. Who fans will switch off. The buzz isn't there & she's not pretty enough.
2.  
   IESR from West Midlands says:

   Jul 16, 12:47

   Rose was brilliant and Martha followed on well and am pleased she will return mid series. Will look forward to seeing her in Torchwood. A BIG NO TO CATHERINE TATE.
3.  
   DL from My Living Room says:

   Jul 16, 12:15

   Neither of them match up to Billie Piper's 'Rose'. Martha is a poor assistant. There is just no believable chemistry there, unlike with Rose and The Doctor. Catherine's character was good but I don't think she'll work as a more permanent choice.
4.  
   Louise from glasgow says:

   Jul 13, 13:50

   you cant beat billie piper as rose she was the best assistant!
5.  
   sophie parrott from york says:

   Jul 12, 18:20

   i like martha better because she is tronger and saved the doctor in the last epoisode

Comments page 10 of 22