Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?

Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?

With an all-star cast and Lost co-creator JJ Abrams directing, will Star Trek XI satisfy the show's highly critical fans, or will the Trekky boots prove too big to fill?

 

Your comments

 
  1.  
    kong from mountain top cave says:
    Nov 26, 17:41

    come on trekky fans,all the films, accept the' wrath of khan' have been ordinary,the tv series are great,specially when the ratings are low and they put in a 7 of 9 or make sure theres a tapall(spelt wrong, ?i'm sure trekky geek will inform me) in it

    Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?
    No
  2.  
    James from Devon says:
    Nov 26, 15:29

    I bought the Star Trek films box set, all 10 in there. I'm sure the people involved are good actors and it will be a good movie but for me personally Shatner defined the Kirk character as did the other actors in their respective roles.
    It's like in the last movie they had a young Pickard who looked nothing like Patrick Stewart.
    They should have gone for a Star Trek: Enterprise (or similar) movie not a rehash.

    Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?
    No
  3.  
    Martin Smith from Hertfordshire says:
    Nov 26, 10:38

    They've got it all wrong yet again in the trailer they are building the ship on the planet. In ST TOS it was built in space dock.They just don't want to fallow the story line of the original series.

    Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?
    No
  4.  
    frank from wigan says:
    Nov 25, 11:34

    this is not a new series we all know the origins off the crew there is no need to make films like this star trek needs to go on into the future and no one will fill shatners boots let alone the whole crew

    Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?
    No
  5.  
    james from london says:
    Nov 25, 05:47

    why, oh why, oh why do they release prequels more advanced then the sequels. they did it with Enterprise, the ship was more advanced and better designed then the Enterprise in the original series. then there's all the new races they discovered, what happened to them. what happened to that big ravine that got cut into the west coast of America, it didn't appear on any maps or images of earth taken from space in ST:TOS or ST:TNG. then there's the Klingons in Kirks time they had flat foreheads, in TNG they had wrinkled foreheads, in Enterprise set 80 years or so before Kirk they had wrinkled foreheads. if their going to make a prequel at least at the continuity right. of course they'll just use that big cop out machine they got aka the holo-deck and say it's just a holo adventure.

    Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?
    No

Report this comment:

This will never be published on the site.

Please tick if you are happy for us to contact you about your report if we have further queries.

Contains offensive language

Contains racist or sexist language

Is a personal attack

Is spamming or advertising

Other

 

Comments page 5 of 73

Your vote: the results

Will Star Trek XI live up to the hype?

No
35%
35%
Yes
65%
65%

Add your view now

This comment board is closed.

Debate status

  • Total comments : 363
  • Allowed comments : 363
  • Blocked comments : 0
  • Waiting for moderation : 0